There's a hot debate raging on my BabyCenter birth board right now, and I'm curious to hear what all of you think:
(***After reading several of your comments, I absolutely agree with the idea of celebrating the arrival of subsequent children with "Meet And Greets," or pampering the mom-to-be (because heck, we need some spoiling!) with a get-together... I realized -- thanks to your comments -- that it is the demand for PRESENTS and the (as Kori said) greediness that I really object to! I also like the idea of registering at Babies R Us to get that 10% off coupon -- I'd forgotten about that!***)
I have to admit, my views on this topic are colored by my family -- specifically my grandmother and great aunts. When I was pregnant with G, they went all out to throw me a huge shower in my hometown.
My pregnancy just happened to coincide with a second cousin's third pregnancy. Even though it was her third, this pregnancy was special for many reasons. For one thing,
it was her first child in almost a decade. Second, it was her first boy. And third, it was the first child for her second husband. So I was shocked when my family announced -- at my shower -- that my cousin would not be getting another shower for her new addition. When her in-laws threw a shower anyway, half of my family refused to attend or send a gift.In my opinion, that kind of behavior is absolutely tacky. But I do understand where my relatives are coming from... to a point.
Baby C is my second child in less than three years. When my family hosted the aforementioned shower, DH & I did not know if G would be a boy or a girl, so just about everything we received -- including the big, pricey items -- were gender-neutral. In going through G's old stuff, I've found I can reuse just about everything other than her clothes. And even that isn't a problem; I have four great friends (all of whom are done having children) who gave me their sons' entire wardrobe, meaning I have far more boys clothes than I ever had for my little girl.
Sure, there were some things I simply wanted: new bedding (had to be in Duke blue, to go with C's basketball-themed room), new diapers (cloth this time; look at me, saving
I had two friends ask if they could throw me a shower. I was flattered and honored, but I politely declined. It just didn't feel right to me. So, here are my rules for a second shower:
#1: Children must be at least five years apart-- or a far enough distance apart that you've discarded all your old baby stuff because it was worn out, had gone out of style or was taking up too much closet space in your home.
#2: Children must be of different genders (this rule is waived if children are a decade or more apart).
#3: The same person shouldn't host a shower for the same woman twice. That's a rule that shouldn't be broken whether you're talking about a second baby shower or a second bridal shower. Spread the love around!
#4: A second shower should be more understated than the first. For example, I've been to second showers that have a theme -- such as a diaper shower (as these are always a useful gift) or a food shower (which I think are a wonderful idea for a mom who will be coping with both a newborn and a young child). But having a full-blown second shower for a mom having her second girl in 18 months? I think that's over the top.
#5: All the above rules are waived if (A) the child is the first for either parent, (B) the parents have moved since having their first child, meaning this new baby will be showered by a completely new group of friends, or (C) there are special circumstances -- you always need flexibility to party, even with rules!
Modify mine, or add your own!







